You did everything right. You obtained your green card through a legitimate process. You have lived in the United States for five years with a clean record. You have built your life here, established your career, and paid into the system. And then you apply for citizenship, go through the naturalization process, sit down for your interview, and get denied. Not because of anything criminal. Not because of fraud. Because of your taxes.
This is happening. It is happening more frequently than it used to, and it is catching applicants completely off guard because historically, tax issues were manageable in the context of a citizenship application. That may no longer be the case.
What is the connection between taxes and citizenship eligibility?
U.S. citizenship through naturalization requires applicants to demonstrate good moral character during the statutory period leading up to their application, which is generally the three years preceding the application for spouses of U.S. citizens or the five years for most other permanent residents. Good moral character is a broad legal standard that encompasses a range of behaviors and obligations, and one of the factors USCIS considers is whether the applicant has met their tax obligations.
Filing and paying taxes is a legal requirement in the United States. For immigration purposes, failing to file required tax returns or failing to pay taxes owed has historically been treated as a negative factor in a citizenship case. But the threshold for how seriously USCIS weighs tax issues has shifted, and what was once considered manageable is now in some cases resulting in outright denials.
What is changing about how USCIS treats tax payment plans?
Here is where the situation has become particularly concerning. For years, immigration attorneys and applicants operated under a well-established understanding. If you owed back taxes to the IRS and had entered into a formal payment plan, you were considered to be addressing your tax obligations. USCIS would review the payment plan, confirm that you were making regular and consistent payments as required by the IRS agreement, and approve your citizenship case on the basis that you were in good standing with your tax obligations even if the balance had not been paid in full.
That understanding is now being challenged by what is happening in practice. There are increasing reports of citizenship applications being denied for applicants who are on IRS payment plans and who have been making their required payments consistently. In some of these cases, the applicant had paid the plan in full by the time of the interview. The balance was zero. The tax debt had been completely resolved before they sat down with the officer. And the case was still denied.
This would have been extraordinarily rare before. It is now happening with enough frequency that immigration attorneys are raising it as a serious concern that applicants need to be aware of before they file.
Who is most at risk?
Any applicant with a history of unfiled tax returns is at risk. Any applicant who has owed taxes and entered into a payment plan with the IRS is at risk. And based on what is being observed in recent cases, even applicants who have fully resolved their tax debt through a completed payment plan may face scrutiny and potentially denial under the current environment.
The risk is not limited to people who never filed. It includes people who filed late. It includes people who owe taxes from prior years and are making payments. It includes people who had payment plans that are now paid off. The common thread is any history of tax noncompliance, even noncompliance that has been fully addressed and resolved.
Why is this happening now?
The current administration has placed increased emphasis on a broad range of compliance factors in immigration cases, and tax obligations fall squarely within that framework. USCIS officers have always had discretion in evaluating good moral character, and the weight given to specific factors can shift depending on policy priorities and officer guidance. What is happening now reflects a stricter interpretation of tax compliance as a component of good moral character, and that stricter interpretation is producing outcomes that would have been unusual or unprecedented in prior years.
There is no specific new regulation that has been announced on this point. The change is being observed through outcomes, through the experiences of applicants and attorneys in the field, and through the pattern of denials that were not happening at this rate before. That makes it harder to predict exactly where the line is, which is precisely why getting ahead of it before you file is so important.
What should you do before applying for citizenship?
Do not file your naturalization application without first having a detailed consultation with an experienced immigration attorney who will go through your tax history thoroughly. This is not an optional step. It is essential preparation for anyone who has any history of tax issues, however minor or however fully resolved they may seem.
Before filing, pull your tax transcripts for every year in the statutory period. Confirm that every return that should have been filed was filed. Confirm that any amounts owed have been addressed. If you are on a payment plan, understand that this may now be a risk factor even if you have been making payments consistently. If you have paid off a prior payment plan, understand that the history of that plan may still be examined.
An attorney can evaluate your specific situation, identify any issues that need to be addressed before you file, and advise you on the timing and strategy that gives your case the best possible outcome. Filing without doing this review first is a risk that is simply not worth taking when the stakes are five years of building toward citizenship.
Do not let a tax issue you thought was resolved be the reason your citizenship is denied.
Download our free Ultimate Marriage Green Card Guide at MarriageImmigrationLaw.com, join Attorney John Khosravi, Esq. live every Tuesday at 4 PM PT / 7 PM ET on YouTube, LinkedIn, Instagram, and TikTok for a free Q&A, or book a one-on-one consultation to talk through your specific situation. Schedule a consultation at JQKLaw.com/contact
